Expert in study

Given that `f(x)` is a function which of the following statements are true: i If `f` is continuous at `x=c` , then `f'(c)` exists.ii If `f'(c)`... |

Register to add an answer
answers: 1
480 cents

Let's go from the top to bottom on this one.


(i) If `f` is continuous at `x=c`, then `f'(c)` exists.

Well, let's look at what it means for `f(x)` to be continuous and differentiable. The definition for continuity is given by:

`lim_(x->c) f(x) = f(c)`

So, we know that that limit holds true for the domain of the function. However, if we look at the conditions for differentiability, we see two: that `f` is continuous, and that `f` is "smooth." Another way to think of this, the derivative of `f` must be continuous at `x=c`.

So, in order to show that (i) is not true, we just need to find a counterexample. In other words, we need a continuous function that is not differentiable at all points. This function comes to mind:

`f(x) = |x|` (absolute value function)

If we plot this function we get:

Now, maybe you can see that the graph isn't "smooth" at x = 0. Well, let's show the derivative to make clear the discontinuity:

The derivative clearly does not exist at `f(0)`. Therefore, (i) must be false.

(ii) If `f'(c)` exists, then `f` is continuous at `x=c`.

Well, if you look at our answer for the previous question, we stated explicity that in order for the derivative to exist, the function must be both continuous and smooth at a certain point.

Therefore, if `f` is differentiable at `x=c` then it must be continuous!

(ii) must be true.

(iii) `lim_(x->c)f(x) = f(c)`

Well, this, as we discussed above, is a definition for continuity.  However, we made no stipulation other than that `f(x)` is a function. Not every function is continuous, therefore (iii) must be false. Well, true sometimes, but in math, we say false when it's true sometimes, like in (i)!

(iv) if `f` is continuous on `(a,b)` then `f` is continuous on `[a,b]`.

Well, this is tricky if you mix up your interval notation! Remember, parantheses indicates an open interval. This means that `f` being continuous does not necessarily apply to `a` or `b`! So, when we put the closed brackets on the interval, we include `a` and `b`! We don't know what's going on at those points based on the premise!

Here's an example: `f(x) = 1/x`

` `Now, don't get worried about the rational/hyperbolic function, it's just there to illustrate a point. Let's say our open interval is `(0, 1)`. Well, we know we can equate the limit from the left and right for any point between 0 and 1; however, can we do the same at 0 and 1?

Let's look at the graph:

Well, it certainly looks continuous at `x=1` but what's going on at 0? Does that line ever cross the y-axis?

Well, if we evaluate `f(x) = 1/x` you'll see that we'd divide by 0 if `x=0`

` `Another way to see that the function is not continuous is to see the graph of the negative side, too:

Even if the graph on the right crossed the y-axis, clearly the limit from the right is NOT the limit from the left! Therefore

`lim_(x->0) 1/x` does not exist!

So, two things can happen when you go from an open interval to a closed one. You may include a point that is not defined on the function, or you may include a point whose limit does not exist.

Either way, (iv) is false.

Hope that helps!

For answers need to register.
Expert in study
About us
For new users
For new experts
Terms and Conditions