Expert in study

Is Guns, Germs, and Steel an example of environmental determinism? |

Register to add an answer
answers: 1
406 cents

Yes.  Guns, Germs, and Steel is an example of environmental determinism.  However, it embraces one type of determinism by rejecting another.

One type of environmental determinism held that people from harsher environments ended up being more successful because they had to work hard to survive.  People from the tropics had life easy and became culturally lazy.  Diamond emphatically rejects this.

However, he still says that environment determines outcomes.  We can see this, for example, in Chapter 2 where he argues that Polynesian societies evolved into different types based on the environments in which they arose.

Diamond's whole argument is that environmental factors determine which societies succeed and which do not.  This is a form of environmental determinism.

For answers need to register.
Expert in study
About us
For new users
For new experts
Terms and Conditions